St Mary's Thrift Shop - Elm Grove, Wisconsin

Introduction to St Mary’s Thrift Shop

For those seeking affordable clothing, household goods, and a chance to support a worthwhile cause, St Mary’s Thrift Shop stands as a premier option. Located in Elm Grove, Wisconsin, this thrift store offers a diverse selection of items at remarkably low prices. It’s a beloved community hub operated by St. Mary’s Evangelical Lutheran Church, and a significant contributor to local charitable initiatives. This comprehensive guide will provide potential visitors with detailed information about the shop, its location, services, and overall value.

Address: 13150 Juneau Blvd, Elm Grove, WI 53122.

Phone: 2627846644.

Website: stmaryeg.org.

About St Mary’s Thrift Shop

St Mary’s Thrift Shop is more than just a retail outlet; it’s a vital extension of St. Mary’s Evangelical Lutheran Church’s mission to serve the community. The proceeds generated from the shop’s sales directly benefit various local charities and organizations. The shop’s operation is entirely volunteer-run, emphasizing a commitment to both affordability and community engagement. The organization consistently strives to provide a welcoming and efficient shopping experience for all patrons. The specialties of the shop are centered around offering gently used clothing, furniture, and various household items at significantly reduced costs.

Key Features and Amenities

• Wide Variety of Goods: The shop boasts a vast inventory that rotates regularly, featuring clothing for all ages and sizes, furniture, kitchenware, books, toys, and sporting goods.
• Competitive Pricing: Items are priced to be extremely affordable, making it an ideal destination for budget-conscious shoppers.
• Same-Day Delivery: For added convenience, St Mary’s Thrift Shop offers same-day delivery within a limited radius.
• Accessibility: The shop is designed to be wheelchair accessible, with both an entrance and parking lot that comply with accessibility standards.
• Quick Visit: The layout is designed for a quick visit, allowing shoppers to efficiently browse and find what they need.
• Credit Card Acceptance: Shoppers can utilize credit cards for their purchases, providing flexibility and ease of payment.

Customer Feedback and Reputation

The St Mary’s Thrift Shop has garnered consistently positive feedback from its patrons. Currently, the shop has 69 reviews on Google My Business, with an average opinion of 4/5. These reviews highlight the shop’s friendly staff, diverse selection, and reasonable prices. Customers frequently commend the shop’s commitment to charitable causes and its positive impact on the community. Here’s a summary of common themes found in the reviews:

• Positive Aspects: Customers consistently praise the affordability, the friendly volunteers, and the surprising quality of the items found.
• Areas for Improvement: Some reviewers suggest expanding the selection of certain categories, such as men’s clothing.

Location and Directions

St Mary’s Thrift Shop is conveniently located at 13150 Juneau Blvd in Elm Grove, Wisconsin. Elm Grove is a suburb of Milwaukee, situated in Waukesha County. The shop is easily accessible via major roadways. Directions: From I-94, take the Elm Grove Boulevard exit. Turn right onto Juneau Boulevard and proceed for approximately one mile. The shop will be on your left side.

Additional Information

Other points of interest: The shop’s commitment to sustainability is evident in its focus on reusing and repurposing items. It’s a practical and ethical shopping choice. The organization actively seeks donations of gently used goods to support its operations. To learn more about the shop or to inquire about donating items, please visit the website at stmaryeg.org or contact them directly by phone at 262-784-6644.

👍 Reviews of St Mary's Thrift Shop

Heather L.

2/5

This thrift shop used to be a great spot to find clothes and shoes at a decent used price. Not anymore, the last few times we have gone I have actually said out loud to other shoppers how ridiculously overpriced certain items are. The sentiment is shared among many shoppers. The idea of a thrift shop is to pass items along that are affordable and not like a consignment shop price point. I recommend the manager reconsiders how they approach a thrift shop, and pricing should follow accordingly.

Jeanne A.

5/5

The mission of St. Mary's Thrift shop is to support the church and school with the revenue from the sales of the donations from our generous community. We strive to fairly price the items. Please, keep in mind, we are not professionals, just volunteers that want to give back. We love our customers and the ability to help the church.

Kathleen P. D.

3/5

St. Mary’s has been my Church for 52-years. I Love the Thrift Shop and most of the Volunteers are very nice. The Manager however, who is a very well paid employee, is a rather harsh woman when she interacts with customers.

Cal

1/5

Prices are laughable. Here are three examples:

- A dented, USED Yeti water bottle for $25.

- A moderately cool sweater for $25.

- An ugly, WORN sweater you could have bought from Kohls for $6 15 years ago.

There are so many items in this store you can legitimately buy cheaper for new.

What used to be an awesome thrift shop has become the epitome of greed.

Tracy M.

5/5

Best thrift store! Have had sales up to 70 percent off! Not over priced! Keep up the great work that you do for others!

Johnathan T.

1/5

This was my favorite shop for years, now it has become the absolute worst! I loved the boutique area. But when you listen to the staff belittle customers or other staff members, unprofessional. Manager Jackie was literally accosted by another manager, Kathy? Jackie cried, packed her things, and left. This manager said “this is my store”. This manager is always hostile and also aggressive. Living across the street I see this manager frequently filling her car with items….. it would be nice if those items made it to the sales floor. Not an inviting Catholic environment. Please do better, and remember “God sees everything, even when the world turns a blind eye.”

Eva B.

5/5

Under new management!! The shop continues to offer new and like-new items at very reasonable prices, with hidden gems galore. They are very selective for the merchandise offered; no dirty, broken, junky things. Wonderful, helpful volunteers. Many shoppers come weekly! There's lots to discover!

Smitastic

1/5

They have decided to go with the Goodwill/St Vince model, receive items for free, and sell them for the going online rate. Unfortunately unlike Goodwill, this is supposed to be a charity. Why even have the thrift store, just put everything online and close. I'll pass!